Secrets in the Closet

A/N I would like to thank everyone who rated and reviewed this story. lia200304, girlwithpearlearring (hope your still reading) and especially Jhoy who left a really detailed review. I'm always up for constructive criticism. If anyone has any suggestions on where they would like this story to go, or things they would want to see happen in the story feel free to write that in a review or email me at almostboredstraight@yahoo.com and I will take every suggestion into consideration!

Chapter 3

“I told Steve to be here as soon as football practice ends.” I told Ally as I watched her unload the dishwasher.

“Ok….” Ally said.

“I want you to try to fuck him.”

“What? Why?” Ally asked, whirling around to face me.

“Why? Because I said so. Just do it.” I replied then left the room before she had a chance to say anything.

An hour later I sat on the couch, my leg bouncing, hardly able to contain my excitement. The TV was on but I couldn’t concentrate on it. It actually worried me how excited I was about my new slave. I didn’t like being overly dependant on anyone or anything. But I chalked it up to the newness of Steve. I had already done almost everything known to man to Ally, and Steve was so much different than anyone I had enslaved before.

I almost jumped out of my skin when the knock came at the front door. I quickly smashed the cigarette I had been smoking out in the ashtray, then leapt to my feet. Ally came around the corner from the kitchen to see what was happening.

“Answer the door, and remember what I told you!” I whispered frantically.

“Where are you gonna be?” Ally asked.

I didn’t bother to answer such a dumb question, instead I grabbed some lotion from the table, crossed the room and hide in the coat closet. The door had slanted wooden slates across the front. It afforded a perfect view of the living room without being seen.

I watched Ally pause for a few seconds staring at the closet, before she walked over and answered the door.

“Hey Steve, come on in.” Ally said.

“Hey Ally how’s it going?” Steve asked politely.

“I’m good, how are you?” Ally said as she lead him over to the couch and sat down.

Steve sat next to her but not to closely. “I’m fine, thanks. So where’s Dustin? He told me to come over as soon as I could.”

“Umm… He’s not here right now, but he told me to tell you to wait here until he gets back.” Ally said.

I cringed in the dark closet, my sister never could tell a decent lie. I knew she was dying of embarrassment inside because of what I was making her do. She had always been painfully shy and making her seduce a man had to be torture for her.

“Oh…ok.” Steve replied.

Ally was looking around awkwardly, as if she didn’t know what to do next.

What the fuck! Do something! I screamed inside.

Thankfully my cell was in my pocket. I took it out, flipped it open, and typed a text to my sister.

‘Tell him u think he’s hot and u’ve always have a crush on him.’ I sent the text. I heard Ally’s cell go off, and saw her read my message.

‘Do I have to?’ She text back.

‘YES’ I replied.

Ally cleared her throat nervously. I peered through the slates in the door and saw her edging closer to Steve on the couch.

“Can I tell you something?” Ally turned to Steve and asked.

Steve shrugged and said, “Sure, go ahead.”
“Well… this is a little hard to say… I’ve had a crush on you ever since you started hanging out with my brother… and I just wanted to tell you I think your really hot.” Ally said turning slightly red.

“Wow Ally. I mean I’m really flattered. I never knew you felt that way.” Steve said avoiding eye contact.

‘Kiss him’ I text Ally.

She checked her phone quickly then went for it. Steve was looking the other way and didn’t even see it coming so her kiss landed on his cheek. Just as I was about to text her again Steve turned toward Ally, grabbed the back of her hair, and started kissing her passionately. I was more than a little surprised to say the least. I thought it would take a lot more effort.

I saw Steve grab Ally’s thighs and pull her forward, making her lie down on the couch. Still kissing he followed her down until he was lying on top of her. In the closet I was fighting the impulse to burst out and kick the shit out of Steve for touching what belonged to me. Sure I had set it up but Steve should know better… Oh well there was plenty of time to punish him soon enough.

Ally broke the kiss to pull her shirt over her head. Steve‘s shirt and wife beater followed next, revealing his toned upper body. I was beginning to think he might have been wrong about Steve. Maybe he did like girls too, after all. While I was pondering Steve’s sexual preferences I undid my fly and pulled my already hard cock out. I squeezed some lotion into my palm and started to slowly stroke myself while I watched Steve and Ally kiss passionately on the couch.

Steve ripped Ally’s cloth skirt off and her thong was soon flung halfway across the room. His dark head lowered and Steve buried his face between her thighs. Ally’s head fell backwards, her eyes closed, and she moaned loudly. Steve’s head moved up and down as I watched him lick her. I tried to stroke myself in time with his licks and was soon breathing heavily myself.

I watched as Ally’s orgasm built. Heard her moans deepen, her voice turned huskier as she begged him not to stop. Soon I saw her whole body stiffen, her back arched, and she was suddenly totally silent. Classic signs she was cumming. After a minute her body relaxed again as the pleasure slowly faded away. But Steve didn’t stop until Ally scooted away from him and sat up. She reached down and tugged on his shirt so he would sit up to.

Then I saw the back of Ally’s blond head start slowly making it’s way downward. She kissed down Steve’s neck, hairless chest, and ripped abs until she was stopped by his jeans. Her thin hands reached out to undo the button and zipper but Steve stopped her and pulled her back up for a kiss. I tucked my dick back in my pants. That was all I needed to see.

The closet door opened with a bang as it bounced off the wall. Ally and Steve froze on the couch and Steve stared at me with surprised horror.

“Well well well… look what we have here!” I laughed.
Steve looked over at Ally for some kind of explanation, but she just turned away in embarrassment.

“What’s going on?” Steve asked, turning back to me.

“Oh just a little game. Do you want to know what you’ve won?” I replied walking over to stand in front of Steve who was still sitting on the couch.

I didn’t wait for a response. Instead I pulled my dick out and said, “suck it.”

Steve looked over at Ally. His whole face turning a shade of red that any tomato would be envious of.

“Dustin…” Steve said quietly.

“I said suck it! If your worried about Ally, you just proved what you are to her.” Dustin said growing more annoyed by the minute.

After a few more moments of nothing happening I got fed up, grabbed the back of Steve’s head by his hair, and shoved my dick in Steve’s face. Steve parted his lips ever so slightly and gently licked up my shaft, swirling around the head.

Out of the corner of his eye I saw Ally start to get up to leave the room. “Stay.” I commanded her. Wordlessly she obeyed. “Watch.” I specified. I wanted her to see this.

Steve seemed to abandon his previous inhibitions and started to suck my cock with great gusto. Taking almost all of my length into his warm, wet mouth at once. He was getting better at this. I moaned as I watched Steve start to suck faster and faster. Soon, almost embarrassingly so, I was ready to cum. I had to shove Steve’s head away from my dick before it was too late and the fun ended.

“Take off your pants and get down on all fours.” I ordered. “Ally get the lube.” I added and watched her walk naked from the room.

Steve looked shocked, scared, and almost ecstatic, all at the same time. But he obeyed faster than he ever had before.

When Ally returned with a small purple squeeze bottle of lube Steve was already on all fours in the middle of the living room, totally naked. I stood behind him enjoying the view. I jerked my head at Ally indicating I wanted her to stand where I was now, while I walked around to the front.

Steve looked a little confused when he saw me come around in front of him. I chuckled at his eagerness. Steve would have to work a lot harder if he wanted me to actually fuck him. Instead I knelt in front of Steve. This time Steve didn’t need any encouragement and immediately started to suck me off.

“Give him what he wants Ally.” I ordered. I felt Steve pause for a second before continuing his work. Ally squeezed a tiny amount of lube on her finger. I reached forward and pushed on Steve’s lower back, making him arch his ass upward.

“Spread ‘em!” I said.

When Steve obeyed Ally carefully inserted only one of her slender fingers into his ass. Steve moaned loudly around my dick, making his whole mouth vibrate, which felt amazing. A thin trail of saliva ran from Steve’s full mouth.

“Add another finger and fuck him.” I said, my voice hoarser.

Ally did as she was told. Steve started to hump backwards as she finger fucked him, wanting more and more. Meanwhile he had managed to take my whole length in his mouth until Steve’s lips were flush with my skin. Reaching up Steve cradled my balls in his hand, gently massaging and pulling on them ever so slightly.

“Another finger Ally.” I said. It turned me on beyond belief watching my naked sister finger this guy who looked like a body builder.

Steve moaned and my dick almost slipped out of his mouth. He quickly recovered, but didn’t stop moaning. He sucked me harder and faster until I felt sweat drip down my face from the effort of holding my climax off as long as possible. Steve humped back against Ally’s hand, while she slammed her three fingers inside him as hard as she could.

“One more Ally.” I said and moaned as I watched her obey.

All of a sudden Steve let out a muffled shout. I looked down to see him releasing his load all over the carpet without anyone even touching his dick. After seeing that I knew I couldn’t hold back anymore. I jerked Steve’s head back and grabbed my dick. I pointed it at Steve’s face, and not a moment to soon because a split second after I shot my load all over the other man’s face.

A few minutes later we were all still lying, exhausted, on the carpet. I listened as all our breathing gradually returned to normal. Eventually when no one moved or said anything I grew bored.

Bianca’s probably going to stop by later. I need to eat. And shower… Random thoughts marched across my mind.

“Alright, I’m done.” I said groaning a little as I stood up. “Get up. Get dressed. Get the fuck out.” I said looking down at both of them.

Steve hurried to get dressed but I saw Ally taking her sweet time. “You too Ally.” I clarified. She looked at me with a hurt expression written all over her face. I shot her a warning glance before she dared to contradict me in front of Steve.

After I shut the door behind them I peeked out the living room window. Barely pulling the curtain aside I watched Ally get into Steve’s red mustang and drive off together.