Caught

Caught red-handed.
By Puppy
Puppy2002@stories.com

Rating: NC-17
Genre: Incest. Dad/Daughter, Dad/Son, and Bro/Sis
Series: 2/?
Summary: A few months after starting a relationship with her dad, Stacy gets caught again, this time by her brother and sister.
Feedback: Yes please, constructive criticism welcome, flames ignored.
Archiving: Anywhere you like.
Author’s note: This is the second story in the ‘caught’ series. Please read ‘Caught Cybering’ before this one, it will make more sense that way. This story is set six months after the first, and it’s a fair bit longer than the first story. Stacy is now nineteen. Enjoy J
------------------------

Caught red-handed.
By Puppy

Part One.

Well folks, a lot has happened in the past six months. So I’ve come back to give you the latest updates on my life. Things have been just great, well better than great; more of my fantasy seems to be coming true, piece-by-piece. I’m here to tell you what happened when dad and me got caught. It was our fault really one for being careless and two for mucking around in the bath. But every action has consequences, and what amazing consequences they were indeed!

Anyway, I’d better start telling the story at the beginning, I have a habit of wanting to tell you the conclusion without trying to explain it all first. I’ll have you know that after the dad caught me online, things have been going well for the two of us. I just love him loads, and we have a great sex life. He still loves mom and I don’t mind sharing him with her really, even if it is without her knowledge. We still think she’d flip if she found out though, in a way, he’s cheating on her. We can’t help it though, we can’t help the way we feel about each other. He’s like my dad and my new boyfriend all rolled into one, it’s an amazing combination. It must be a hard thing for people who have never done it to understand. Many people would be quick to condemn what they don’t understand. It’s dumb, but then that’s a fact of life.

That day Lucy and Greg caught us was a real weird day. I just got into the bath, same as I do every Saturday night. I always spend at least an hour in there, soaking. Well, mom had gone out with some friends from work, and it was our understanding that she wouldn’t be back four a few hours yet. Yes, mom loved her late nights out on the town. Dad came in to hand me a cup of hot chocolate, which he put on the window ledge. He had that certain daredevil look in his eyes. I knew he wanted to join me, so I said, “Come on then.”

He stripped off and got in with me. While this bath was a bit too small for us to have sex, it didn’t mean we couldn’t have some fun and games. I loved it when he put a couple of his fingers inside me and started moving them around, just he he was doing that particular day. Suddenly, the door opened, and Lucy and Greg walked in. So, with dad’s fingers up my pussy, and my hand wrapped firmly around his cock, we both yelled, “GET OUT!”

But they both just stood there, leaving us to pull away from each other. They just froze like statues with gaping mouths! Greg said, “WHAT THE FUCK is going on here?”

I said, “Can’t you two just get out?”

Lucy was too disillusioned to say a word. So dad said, “If you two leave now, we will explain it all to you, I promise. Oh and don’t tell your mother.”

They both nodded and left. I said, “Shit, what can we say to them. They might end up reporting us.”

Dad said, “They won’t love, we can try to get them to understand us. Also, we could make them an offer.”

“What kind of an offer.”

“Well, ask them if they want to join in. You know, in exchange for not going to the police or your mom.”

“We could do.” I said thoughtfully, but I had a nasty gut feeling that this time tomorrow we’d be on the inside of a jail cell.

We got out of the bath and got into our bathrobes. I was shit scared; I mean really shit scared, like fuck!

We went down to the living room and there they were sitting on the sofa. They looked at us like we were from a different planet or something when we walked in. Lucy was the first one to break the awkward silence that had descended upon the room, “Dad, Stacy, how could you do that? I mean it’s awful.” She had tears in her eyes, she was obviously traumatized, and this wasn’t the best way for them to find out about our little affair.

“I love him.” I said, “It may be hard for you to believe, but I really do. It’s not awful, we have a special bond which makes it a very wonderful thing.”

Greg piped up, “You’re perverted if you think that incest is a wonderful thing. I mean what the hell are you thinking? He’s your dad for fucks sake!”

“Leave her alone Greg.” Dad protested.

“And you…” He continued, yelling at my dad, “You’re a sick weirdo, talk about being a freak Jesus Christ!”

“Greg, I love her, and she loves me. It comes naturally to us, we can’t help how we feel.”

Lucy continued to cry, “How long has this been going on?”

“For the past six months.” I said.

“SIX MONTHS!!” Yelled Greg, “Stacy, we’re worried about you. Are you sure you don’t want to get the cops or something.”

“Now listen here Greg, Lucy.” I snapped, “I know it’s hard for you to understand, but I’m in this of my own free will. We love each other, and that’s all that matters now. How can it be wrong to do something special with somebody you love? Answer me that smart asses? Look, I know you mean well, but you’ve gotten it all wrong. You both seem to think that all incest is abusive or something, and you’re so wrong. I can’t even begin to tell you how wrong you both are. “ I was virtually yelling at this point.

Lucy just looked at me, “Okay sis, don’t have a spaz!”

Greg said, “Stace, I just don’t understand, how the fuck does something as fucked up as this come about anyway?”

Dad looked at me and said, “Go on, you may as well tell them.”

I turned to Greg and Lucy, “Well, first off, about a year ago I had a fucked up dream, I mean a really fucked up dream. I was in this mud bath with like the whole family in there totally starkers. Next thing I realize I’m having sex with some of you. I was shocked and disgusted at myself at first, and then I started having masturbation fantasies about everyone, and felt guilty. So I did a search on the Internet like, and I came to this incest chatroom. I gained loads of cyber buddies who told me that what I was thinking and feeling was totally normal. Anyway, I was having cyber sex with CoolGuyXX and Gr8sis4U, then when I finished I turned round and there was dad with this cheesy grin. So we talked about it and ended up having sex ‘cos he felt same way about me. So you see, it’s NOT abusive or anything like that. We’ve been having sex ever since and that’s all there is to it really.”

Lucy looked stunned, not that I blamed her. Greg just like sat there with this gaping mouth, almost as if he’d been slapped around the face a w a wet trout. I mean what could they say, I’d just told them point blank.

After a few moments of awkward silence, Greg finally spoke, “Okay, we won’t grass you up. Sorry I yelled at you but it’s just been such a shock, I mean you never told us.”

“Well, what was I supposed to say? ‘Hi Greg, nice day isn’t it? Guess what, I’m having sex with dad.’ Duh, don’t think so somehow.”

“Okay, point taken.”

Dad said, “I’m glad that’s sorted.”

“I still think it’s perverted though.” Said Greg, “I mean it is recognized as a sexual deviance.”

Dad said, “Any form of sex that isn’t the norm could be defined as a deviant. I mean in the past people used to be locked up for being gay, because homosexuality was deemed a terrible thing, now it’s no big deal. You just have to look at things from all angles without being judgmental.”

Lucy said, “Dad, how the fuck do you compare homosexuality to incest, you just can’t! It’s like totally different.”

“All I’m saying, is that people can choose to change their attitudes if they want to. Sometimes, it’s better to try to understand than to be so prejudiced.”


Part Two

For the next few weeks, that was all there was to it. I mean Lucy took longer to come round to the idea than Greg. They started to relax around us again, talk to us like human beings again instead of treating us from we were like from another planet.

It took a while, but they both started giving us the twenty questions. I was more than happy to answer them; I mean they’d actually started to engage their brains rather than the pre-programmed prejudices they’d built up inside them over the years. That’s all it was for weeks on end, questions, questions, and yet more questions. To a de it it got tedious for me and dad, but I was pleased that they showed an interest in learning a bit more about the exact nature of our relationship. This was the point where dad and me had to have some serious conversation.

So basically, we sat down and discussed our feelings. You know, we wanted to know whether or not it would be okay for either of us to go with Lucy or Greg if they got curious enough. As it turned out we were both happy to share if necessary. It was now I found out that dad was bisexual too, and that he had quite a little crush brewing for Greg. How Greg would handle this knowledge we just didn’t know, as far as we knew he was like totally straight. So we agreed to work under that assumption unless Greg showed interest in dad.

It was amazing; you know how we got them to change their minds about almost everything. I’d say it was probably the best turn outcoulcould have realistically hoped for.

Then this particular day I was on the computer, you know, Cybering again. Greg walked in and said, “Those people you’re talking to the cyber family you were going on about?”

“Sure.”

“Listen, Stacy. I don’t know how I supposed to ask this but do you think dad would mind if I shared you with him? I mean I don’t want to cause problems in your current relationship but I think you’re cute.”

I was amazed, I mean this was aam cam come true, ironically. I said, “I already discussed the possibility of sharing with dad before, and he said that it would be fine. Also, I should tell you something that’ll probably surprise you.”

“What’s that?”

“Well, me and Lucy got together two days ago. We thought we’d asked enough questions and we got a bit curious to say the least. Now we understand why you do it.”

“I’m happy for you both Greg. Hey, you know what this means don’t you?”

“No.”

“That we’re starting an incest family. Now we’re only one member short.”

“Mom.”

“Yea.”

“Don’t get too bold, you know how she’d react if she found out about any of this. She won’t be as easy to convert as me and Lucy you k”
”

“You and Lucy were not easy to convert. Not as though we aimed to convert you, just let you see why me and dad were doing it that’s all.”

Grust ust laughed. “Seriously though, I doubt mom is a viable option, we might be able to twist aunt Rachel though.”

“I wouldn’t go that far yet, I mean can you imagine her reaction if she finds out that he son has been chatting up her sister?”

“I don’t think I want to, so point taken.”

Next thing I realize we were like staring into each other’s eyes. I knew what was coming, so I thought I’d make the first move. I just grabbed hold of him and started kissing him, he responded with full force probing my mouth with his tongue. Wow, here I was kissing my brother for the first time. In some ways he was kind of like dad. He groped me in the exact same way as my dad, but he was much more forceful. So we started stripping off like and he pushed a couple of fingers into my already moistening cunt.

His cock was pressing against by belly; I couldn’t resist wrapping my hand around it and start jacking him off. For some reason he didn’t seem to be as big as my dad, it didn’t matter though because we were just enjoying ourselves. Yet again it was get the condom time, I couldn’t wait to see what that cock of his felt like inside me. So I lay back waiting for him to enter me. He didn’t waste any time either. Within a minute or so he was pumping into me furiously, we’d just taken off to a flying start. He seemed to be completelysumesumed with his desire for me, the whole thing was just so deliciously erotic and sexy. For the first time my big brother was taking care of me iactlactly the way I’d wanted him to for the past year or so. He was most definitely going to drive me crazy in the foreseeable future.

Within a few more wild minutes he arched his back, I could feel his whole body tensing as he cum. Just seeing him like that made me cum too, I loved that feeling of being sent into orbit, even for a brief moment. He eventually caught his breath and pulled his now limp dick out of me, then said “Gee sis, that was incredible. You know what, since I’ve done Lucy and you, I’d say I’ve got the best sex life a guy could ask for.”

I laughed, “Yea, you’re pretty good yourself you know.”

“Does this mean we’re up for round two?”

I gave him a devilishly tempting smile, “What do you think?”

“I’ll take that as a yes.” He concluded. Hmmmmm, it was going to take him a little time to locate a second condom…


Part Three

About a week after I’d first had sex with Greg, Lucy said that she desperately needed to talk to me. I wondered what the hell was up with her at first because she looked a bit on the worried side. So I said to her, “Okay sis, what’s up?”

“I don’t think dad fancies me.”

“Why would you think that?”

“He hasn’t made any attempt to chat me up, or talk to me sexy, just nothing.” She almost wailed.

“Have you tried talking to him about it?” I asked.

“No.”

“Then you should. He told me that if any of his children wants a relationship with him, it’s their job to start it, not his.”

“Why?”

“He kinda thinks that if he starts then it might scare you away, just talk to him.”

“Thanks. Oh, and there is one more thing.”

“What’s that?”

“Well, I thing Greg fancies dad too.”

“Cool.”

“Cool? But dad’s straight… isn’t he?”

“Nope, he’s bi. He did say to me a few weeks back that he had a bit of a crush on him.”

“Oh. Well, perhaps I should tell Greg, that way he will know.” She suggested. She sounded a bit surprised at this new information, but life is full of surprises.

“Good idea. Perhaps we should talk to him together.”

“Now that’s an even better idea, will you come with us?”

“Yea sure.”

“Like now?”

“Now?”

“Yea, now.”

“Okay then.”

“Cool.”

So we went to get Greg, he’d just plonked his lazy arse in front of the TV again. Just Typical, there always seemed to be something on the telly that he wanted to watch whenever he was needed. I said, “Greg! Me and Lucy need to talk to you.”

“Fuck off, I’m watching Stargate.” He said playfully

“Charming!” Lucy said, “But we still want to talk to you like now and we kinda won’t take no for an answer.”

“Can’t it wait for half an hour?”

“Aren’t you taping it?”

“Well yea, but…”

At this point I interrupted, “Yea so you can watch it later. But this is interesting and important.”

“Why?”

“Well come with us and we’ll tell you.”

He looked a bit on the exasperated side at this point, he knew that we’d just whine until he gave in, so he came with us and let the video continue recording. We went back upstairs and into my room, I said, “Greg, I have something to tell you that you might be pleasantly pleased to hear. Dad has a crush on you.”

Now he looked shocked, “He does?”

“Yup.” I confirmed.

He just gave me a skeptical look, “Are you sure you’re not just winding me up here?”

“This is no prank.” I assured him, “But if you want to share dad with us, you’re going to have to talk to him yourself.”

“Cool.” He replied, “Where is he now?”

“In the garage I think, but I’d wait until mom’s gone out before you say anything.”

“Yea, that’s only a few minutes from now. By the way, when mom’s gone out, will you watch the video for me while I speak to dad. You know just make sure that you press stop once it’s finished.”

“Yea sure.” Said Lucy.

“Thanks” he said.

So, about ten minutes later mom grabbed her keys and said to us, “I’ll be back later folks, oh and Lucy, don’t forget to do the dishes for us.”

“Won’t do.” She replied.

As soon as mom’s car had left the driveway Lucy went to do the dishes, I stayed put to stop the video and Greg went to talk to dad. I really wanted to eavesdrop on them right now, but resisted the urge. I decided to try to get into Stargate a bit more, at least until they’d finished talking.

Fifteen minutes later, Greg and dad came out of the garage, holding hands. This would be interesting, and from the looks of it things were going well. Greg had one of those cheesy grins on his face, now they were definitely together.

So that concludes our lives up until now, a lot had changed since they caught us in the bathroom that was for sure. Lucy got together with dad a week later, and she couldn’t be happier. It’s just a shame we can’t let mom know, she’d make a wonderful sexy addition to the love we all share. But then that’ll probably be another story.

--------Another chapter will undoubtedly be coming up soon.--------