AFF Fiction Portal

rate_review Reviews

for Halloween 2025

by InvidiaRed

schedule November 24, 2025 at 12:00 AM
"Leaffall"
Once again, you've written a story soaked in Celtic myth and dripping with drama. I have to wonder what the ultimate outcome will be for Darri after selling his soul (No afterlife? Bound to the water fae forever?), but he did win Angaine her freedom and got a bonus water-breathing ability on top of that. He'll probably be persona non grata in the human world unless he starts wearing sunglasses or something (I recently watched Blue Eye Samurai, so...), and he's not fae either, but being half this and half that is a great start to becoming a legendary hero. Or else a cool bartender at an edgy tavern. Great story!
schedule November 21, 2025 at 12:00 AM
Leaffall

I've read several of your "Land" stories, and it is interesting to ponder if this takes place in the same setting.  I didn't quite get that vibe, in spite of the heavy emphasis on dealings with fae, but I could be wrong.  It does do a really nice job of suggesting a wider world and history outside the story, but not going so far that you feel like there was another chapter you were supposed to read

I also loved the way things are established here, piece by piece.  It kept me asking questions, and the answers were a really cool slow reveal.  At first, I was extremely alarmed by the "youth" being dragged in attached to a rope, thinking "Uh-oh, is Darri a slave trader or something?"  Which rapidly led to greater concern when Angaine turned out to be chained to her workstation, which led eventually to the reveal that Angaine isn't his slave, and in fact Darri is the only human who's nice to her.

I also found myself curious about the "sky ore" concept.  My first thought was that it was a reference to iron harvested from iron meteorites, but the references to it throughout the story seem to indicate it's pretty common, and in the first mention Angaine describes her captors having mixed iron with the sky ore, so maybe it's actually something else.

Aside from the story taking place on a sort of equivalent holiday (a fall festival), the story also has an appropriately dark tone.  I remember that the exact moment the Cailleach Mhara offered Darri a "trade"...

“Oh, I think we can find something,” the ancient fae said. She smiled, and it was the same shark’s grin as the fae youth had. “You’ll barely even miss it, I think.”

"...Your SOOOOOOUUUUUL!!!"

Except, uh, actually yes, that is what it is.  If there is one lesson to be taken from this story, it's that if a fantasy creature offers to trade you for something, and says you won't miss it, they mean your soul.

For the record, it was either going to be that joke or bursting into "Poor Unfortunate Souls".  It was a coinflip really.

Joking aside, the dark tone carries through, and the story ultimately plays out as a somewhat different version of the tragedy I'd anticipated.  As soon as the trade was mentioned, I figured Darri would sacrifice his soul for Angaine, and then something bad would happen to her.  I'd assumed it would have something to do with him losing all of the things that made her think relatively fondly of him, and that might have happened given enough time, but instead she's killed after getting well away from the town, since the sea fae's response to Darri being taken to be sacrificed was the magical equivalent of a strategic nuke, and she was clear of the village, but not clear enough.  His choice still results in her death, just in a somewhat more indirect manner.  Still, while the sea fae didn't exactly ingratiate themselves to the reader, no one deserves to die out from slow poisoning, and at least Darri's sacrifice ensured that an entire species wasn't about to die out.

All in all, a suitably grim, moody piece for the creepiest season of the year, and one that showcases your talents for really engaging the reader!
schedule November 16, 2025 at 12:00 AM
Interregnum

"Surreal" might be the best word to describe this one.  There were definitely a few times I thought I knew what the rough outline of the story was, and then it turned out to be sort of a red herring.

At first, this feels like a relatively mundane story about an officer getting called to an abandoned building, albeit with hints that this takes place in a dystopian future (the walls around the city, the fact that certain spaces are measured in tank widths, etc.).  Given that my only experience with the abbreviation comes from the Gundam franchise, I thought FCS meant Fire Control System, like on a warship.

Then I learned what it meant here and thought this might be a reverse WitS (that was rather flattering, I have to add).  However, then things went a different direction again.  I do have to admit I'm not sure what the significance of the FCS being broken was.  The walls around the city and whatnot do ultimately make sense when the exact nature of the setting is revealed, but I'm not sure about the statue.

The final reveal is pretty cool.  It's unclear if anything happened to the Earth, but I got the impression that this city is no longer on Earth, and periodically in order to maintain its status, someone needs to be...assigned, I guess, to be the ruler of the Hellspore, presumably until someone else kills them and takes their position.  I could also have misinterpreted that, so apologies if I did.

I am admittedly somewhat confused about the presence of Hachishakusama in the story.  She's something of a modern yokai, a being out of Japanese urban legend, so I'm not sure what she's doing in what feels like part of Hell.  Then again, the Hellspore may not be region-specific, so it's possible any and all supernatural beings could show up here.

Of course, I do have to mention my appreciation for a gorgeous tall lady as your protagonist.  Jenna must have a specially made seat in her cruiser given her height!

schedule November 16, 2025 at 12:00 AM
You Were Warned

This was a fun little piece of poetry!  I'm not sure if it was entirely meant to do this, but I guess due to reader expectation, there was a shift in how I perceived the poem's focus.  At first, I legitimately thought it was very specific, gradually illuminating one specific story.  It was only by the beginning of the third verse that I realized what was going on, and that this was the poem secretly written in the hearts of everyone following along with a...certain kind of horror movie protagonist.

I have often wondered if it would go like that in real life.  Especially for certain things, I can't help but think we're all so secure in our intelligence due to sitting in a theater or on a couch watching the film, but if we were there, would we make the same mistakes?

Of course, as the poem's very title states, we do have something of a cultural grounding in certain tropes by now, so at least some of us should be able to employ the lessons in the appropriate situations.

One would hope, anyway.

schedule November 1, 2025 at 12:00 AM

Interregnum

I will admit, I tend to find malls creepy even when they're not abandoned, or derelict. BUT, if I were to have to wander around an abandoned, derelict, entirely creepy mall, I would be much happier in the company of a Belgian Malinois. Rex is a Very Good Boy!

Nice and creepy! Thank you!

schedule November 1, 2025 at 12:00 AM

You Were Warned

Oh, touché and well done! 

My younger brother and I were addicted to the Friday night horror movies on television when we were young. It was a nonstop parade of (mostly) B-films from Hammer, and we'd curl up in the living room with all the lights off, a plate of leftover fried chicken, and we would watch movies from 8pm until 4am, or whenever the channel would sign off. (Yes, I'm that old.) This poem is an ode to everything we ever yelled at the television as we indulged ourselves, and I can't tell you how much fun it was. (Wait, is it supposed to be fun? It's Halloween, I know, but still...)

Thank you! 

schedule November 1, 2025 at 12:00 AM

Leaffall, Ah BronxWench its always a pleasure.

 

“Don’t make idle wishes, not at Leaffall. It’s not only the gods who are listening.”

 

Gave me chills. What a wonderful addition. The town did have it coming for awhile now.

schedule October 7, 2025 at 12:00 AM

I adore it!

 

Kudos! A fitting homage if not a eulogy for those whose curiosity outwieghs their survival instinct!